At first I couldn't believe that discussing hand histories with your girlfriend is runitonce elite content.
But I think this could have been really valuable if we could get more insight in the exact thought processes of a (not sure what to call Amy in terms of poker knowledge) recreational player/ very weak reg. Because, to state the obvious, all of us play against these type of players with some decent basic knowledge of poker, it would be of great value to see how they interpret certain sizes/lines/spots.
But the way you two structured it, it was more her asking questions and you explaining, while I would have loved it to be the other way around.
Just a random example, she stated she is scared of monotone flops in that 3b pot on 235ddd, so in stead of you explaining a good strategy, I would have found it more valuable if you would ask her what here gameplan would be with good and weak hands and what she would focus on etc.
She actually asked some good questions though, but you get my point.
Patrick Cronin - I would never leave this comment if I thought of you as someone who was overly sensitive or incapable of handling constructive criticism—in fact, I believe you to be the most capable of receiving criticism out of all of the RIO coaches that I have thus far encountered—and please understand that I get no value out of thoughtlessly criticizing others (I have enough flaws of my own that if I simply wanted to be critical I could spend the rest of my waking life standing in front of a mirror and freestyling self-criticisms). I only leave this comment because I care (despite the fact that that does sound uncomfortably similar to a banal platitude).
The Criticism Sandwich:
I once heard something about a sandwich, where you take a criticism and place it between two compliments, and since every rational person likes sandwiches, let's give that a go. . .
You are likely the most original and idiosyncratic coach (when it comes to your content at least) on this entire site, and you never ever lose points for trying something new and original, especially when you are good at it. There are a massive amount of RIO subscribers, myself included, who seriously appreciate and value your uniqueness, so please continue to exercise your creativity mercilessly. For me, however, this video felt like it missed the bar that you set so high right out of the gate (I bet you're regretting that decision now, aren't ya, Pat! =). But I actually got a little bit sad while watching the video because it slowly dawned on me that I might not be able to make it through this one in its entirety (I did end up completing it though); and that is especially sad because I have watched all of your content with great satisfaction, and have even watched some of your videos 2 or 3 times at this point. In short, I know that you are capable of producing content that is among the absolute highest caliber, and you have already proven that, but this video simply falls short of what you are capable of, not to mention what you have the potential of being capable of (scary). While I won't publicly expound on why I personally believe that this video was not quite up to the incredibly (unfairly?) high standard that we place upon you, please know that I have absolutely nothing against Amy, as she seems like a marvelous woman who obviously helps and supports you in your endeavors, which in my estimation makes her quite the amazing person. And also please know that you are among the most beloved of RIO coaches, and you have earned that admiration and respect based on your quality of content, as well as your quality of character.
Thanks for coaching, Pat. I know that you can't please everyone and that there will always be plenty of harshly critical people waiting for an opportunity to put you down, or egocentric people who erroneously criticize content that is great just because it doesn't suit their own personal preferences, etc. I just hope that you don't count me in their number.
Certainly I am not offended OMGIsildurrrrman12 In fact, you took the time to write a very long and detailed entry in order to voice your criticism in the kindest way possible. I appreciate you and your time and I'm grateful for your feedback. Thank you.
I'm sorry that you did not enjoy or find useful the content. I always try to make something that students can learn from and enjoy, but I'm not sorry I tried. I definitely want to be the type to take big swings and not make "safe videos" where I grind 500z for 40 minutes and toss it at the wall for you guys to watch. I'll wait to see how others feel about this video before commenting further, but I wanted to let you know I appreciate you and the time it took to give that constructive feedback :)
I definitely want to be the type to take big swings and not make "safe videos" where I grind 500z for 40 minutes and toss it at the wall for you guys to watch.
Awesome attitude and I hope you continue this approach.
Even in his replies to critical comments, the DR does not disappoint and only further exemplifies what it means to be not only a great poker player and coach, but also a well-put-together human being. Much respect, brother, and thank you for your reply.
As someone who plays 50NL I enjoyed it. Maybe its more appropriate for Essential but personally I appreciated the analysis of some pretty common spots. Thank you!
Loading 7 Comments...
At first I couldn't believe that discussing hand histories with your girlfriend is runitonce elite content.
But I think this could have been really valuable if we could get more insight in the exact thought processes of a (not sure what to call Amy in terms of poker knowledge) recreational player/ very weak reg. Because, to state the obvious, all of us play against these type of players with some decent basic knowledge of poker, it would be of great value to see how they interpret certain sizes/lines/spots.
But the way you two structured it, it was more her asking questions and you explaining, while I would have loved it to be the other way around.
Just a random example, she stated she is scared of monotone flops in that 3b pot on 235ddd, so in stead of you explaining a good strategy, I would have found it more valuable if you would ask her what here gameplan would be with good and weak hands and what she would focus on etc.
She actually asked some good questions though, but you get my point.
That's cool info and a good structural idea. Thanks for taking the time to make a long, insightful post. Appreciate you.
Patrick Cronin - I would never leave this comment if I thought of you as someone who was overly sensitive or incapable of handling constructive criticism—in fact, I believe you to be the most capable of receiving criticism out of all of the RIO coaches that I have thus far encountered—and please understand that I get no value out of thoughtlessly criticizing others (I have enough flaws of my own that if I simply wanted to be critical I could spend the rest of my waking life standing in front of a mirror and freestyling self-criticisms). I only leave this comment because I care (despite the fact that that does sound uncomfortably similar to a banal platitude).
The Criticism Sandwich:
I once heard something about a sandwich, where you take a criticism and place it between two compliments, and since every rational person likes sandwiches, let's give that a go. . .
You are likely the most original and idiosyncratic coach (when it comes to your content at least) on this entire site, and you never ever lose points for trying something new and original, especially when you are good at it. There are a massive amount of RIO subscribers, myself included, who seriously appreciate and value your uniqueness, so please continue to exercise your creativity mercilessly. For me, however, this video felt like it missed the bar that you set so high right out of the gate (I bet you're regretting that decision now, aren't ya, Pat! =). But I actually got a little bit sad while watching the video because it slowly dawned on me that I might not be able to make it through this one in its entirety (I did end up completing it though); and that is especially sad because I have watched all of your content with great satisfaction, and have even watched some of your videos 2 or 3 times at this point. In short, I know that you are capable of producing content that is among the absolute highest caliber, and you have already proven that, but this video simply falls short of what you are capable of, not to mention what you have the potential of being capable of (scary). While I won't publicly expound on why I personally believe that this video was not quite up to the incredibly (unfairly?) high standard that we place upon you, please know that I have absolutely nothing against Amy, as she seems like a marvelous woman who obviously helps and supports you in your endeavors, which in my estimation makes her quite the amazing person. And also please know that you are among the most beloved of RIO coaches, and you have earned that admiration and respect based on your quality of content, as well as your quality of character.
Thanks for coaching, Pat. I know that you can't please everyone and that there will always be plenty of harshly critical people waiting for an opportunity to put you down, or egocentric people who erroneously criticize content that is great just because it doesn't suit their own personal preferences, etc. I just hope that you don't count me in their number.
Certainly I am not offended OMGIsildurrrrman12 In fact, you took the time to write a very long and detailed entry in order to voice your criticism in the kindest way possible. I appreciate you and your time and I'm grateful for your feedback. Thank you.
I'm sorry that you did not enjoy or find useful the content. I always try to make something that students can learn from and enjoy, but I'm not sorry I tried. I definitely want to be the type to take big swings and not make "safe videos" where I grind 500z for 40 minutes and toss it at the wall for you guys to watch. I'll wait to see how others feel about this video before commenting further, but I wanted to let you know I appreciate you and the time it took to give that constructive feedback :)
Awesome attitude and I hope you continue this approach.
Even in his replies to critical comments, the DR does not disappoint and only further exemplifies what it means to be not only a great poker player and coach, but also a well-put-together human being. Much respect, brother, and thank you for your reply.
As someone who plays 50NL I enjoyed it. Maybe its more appropriate for Essential but personally I appreciated the analysis of some pretty common spots. Thank you!
Be the first to add a comment
You must upgrade your account to leave a comment.